This Mackinac Island fudge has been my holiday lifesaver for years — a small batch of rich, buttery chocolate that always earns compliments and disappears fast. I first tasted this dense, melt-in-your-mouth confection on a family trip to the island, where the fudge shops displayed slabs of glossy chocolate in every flavor. I came home determined to replicate that nostalgic texture using pantry staples and a simple stovetop method, and after a few tweaks the result became our go-to gift and after-dinner treat.

The recipe is deceptively straightforward but rewards attention to temperature and timing. The finished candy is intensely chocolatey with a smooth texture from confectioners' sugar and butter, the light salt balancing the sweetness. It sets firm enough to slice cleanly yet yields a tender bite. I love preparing a single log, wrapping it, and slicing it into neat pieces to tuck into small boxes for neighbors or to serve with coffee at gatherings.

Ingredients

• Unsalted butter: 8 tablespoons (1 stick). Use a quality brand like Plugrá or Kerrygold for a slightly creamier finish; unsalted gives control over final salt level.
• Milk: 1/2 cup whole milk. Whole milk adds richness and helps the mixture reach the right texture; avoid skim if possible.
• Granulated sugar: 1/2 cup. Provides structure during the brief boil; use standard white granulated sugar.
• Brown sugar: 1/2 cup, firmly packed. Adds depth and a subtle molasses note; light or dark both work but dark is richer.
• Salt: Pinch. A small amount of fine salt brightens the chocolate and balances sweetness.
• Vanilla extract: 1 teaspoon. Adds aromatic warmth; use pure extract for best flavor.
• Unsweetened cocoa powder: 1/2 cup. Choose Dutch-processed if you prefer a mellower chocolate note, or natural cocoa for brighter acidity.
• Confectioners' sugar: 2 cups (powdered sugar). This is the major textural ingredient that sets the fudge — sift if lumpy.

Instructions

Prepare equipment and ingredients: Line a baking sheet with parchment paper or a silicone mat and lightly grease the surface. Measure and sift the confectioners' sugar and cocoa so they are lump-free. Have a sturdy rubber spatula ready for mixing. This mise en place keeps the process smooth once the hot mixture is ready. Combine liquids and sugars: In a medium saucepan over medium heat, add 8 tablespoons unsalted butter, 1/2 cup milk, 1/2 cup granulated sugar, 1/2 cup firmly packed brown sugar, and a pinch of salt. Stir gently just to combine; avoid splashing. Bring mixture to a gentle boil. Boil and cook to set time: Once boiling, reduce heat to low and maintain a low rolling boil for 6 minutes, stirring constantly with a heatproof spatula. The constant stirring prevents scorching and promotes even cooking. You are not aiming for a candy thermometer reading here but for a consistent 6-minute gentle boil — this step cooked long enough to dissolve sugars and concentrate the mixture without overcooking into a grainy texture. Cool slightly and flavor: Remove the pan from heat and let the mixture cool for about 2 minutes — just enough so it is not scalding. Stir in 1 teaspoon vanilla extract to preserve its aroma (adding vanilla on very hot syrup will evaporate some of its delicate aroma). Incorporate cocoa and powdered sugar: Off the heat, sift in 1/2 cup unsweetened cocoa powder and gradually add 2 cups confectioners' sugar, stirring vigorously with a spatula until the mass becomes smooth and glossy. If mixture feels too stiff, a tablespoon of milk will loosen it; if too loose, add a bit more confectioners' sugar. The mechanical action of stirring and the temperature are what give the candy its smooth texture. Shape and chill: Turn the fudge out onto the prepared baking sheet and shape it into a rough log or rectangle while still warm. Press into a compact log about 1.5 to 2 inches in diameter for even slicing. Wrap tightly in plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least 30 minutes to set. Slice into pieces with a sharp knife chilled under hot water and dried for clean cuts.

Storage Tips

Store the log wrapped tightly in plastic wrap to prevent moisture migration and flavor pickup. Place wrapped fudge in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to two weeks. For longer storage, wrap each slice in parchment and freeze in a rigid, freezer-safe box for up to three months. Thaw overnight in the fridge and bring to room temperature for 10 to 20 minutes before serving to restore its creamy texture. If slices become sticky after thawing, place them briefly in the fridge to firm up again.

Ingredient Substitutions

If you prefer a dairy-free version, substitute vegan butter and use a non-dairy milk like oat milk — the texture will be slightly different and may be a touch firmer when chilled. For a richer chocolate profile, replace 1 to 2 tablespoons of cocoa with finely chopped bittersweet chocolate, adding it off-heat and stirring until melted. To reduce sweetness, cut back confectioners' sugar by 1/4 cup and add 1 tablespoon more cocoa, but note the fudge will be slightly less tender.

Serving Suggestions

Serve thin slices alongside strong coffee or tea to balance sweetness. Arrange on a small platter with a dusting of cocoa or a sprinkle of flaky sea salt for contrast. For parties, pair with nuts, candied orange peel, or dried cherries to complement the chocolate. Small boxed slices also make elegant edible gifts — tie with twine and attach a handwritten label to evoke that island fudge-shop feel.

Cultural Background

Mackinac Island has long been famous for its fudge shops, a tradition dating to the late 19th century when tourists began bringing home sweets as souvenirs. The island’s confectioners refined a smooth, dense style of fudge that became associated with the region. This stovetop approach is a home-cook adaptation that captures the essence of that style: short, precise cooking followed by gentle incorporation of powdered sugar to achieve a creamy, sliceable confection.

Seasonal Adaptations

In winter, add a teaspoon of cinnamon or a pinch of ground cloves for a cozy spiced version. For summer gatherings, fold in finely chopped toasted almonds and a teaspoon of orange zest for a lively citrus twist. Holiday gift versions can include peppermint extract and a dusting of crushed candy canes, while autumn batches pair well with a tablespoon of maple syrup in place of part of the brown sugar for a maple-chocolate variation.

Meal Prep Tips

Make several logs at once and freeze them individually for quick gift assembly later. Slice frozen logs with a hot knife for clean edges; let the slices rest at room temperature briefly before packing. If preparing for an event, make the fudge two days ahead to allow flavors to mellow and the texture to fully stabilize.

Every time I make this fudge it brings back the chill of lake breezes and the warm glow of island shop windows — and every time it vanishes just as quickly. I hope this method helps you create your own sweet traditions.